Mapiripán, the monument that was but is not anymore
Mapiripán is a small village on the riverbanks of the Guaviare river (centre Colombia) where a terrible massacre occurred in 14th July. That day more than 100 members of the United Self-Defences of Colombia arrived in Mapiripán supported by the Colombian army which provided military planes and trucks to mobilise the paramilitaries. The paramilitary considered Mapiripán a stronghold for the FARC-EP guerrilla and wanted to seize control of the area by eliminating guerrilla members and their supporters. For a week the paramilitaries took people from their homes at night, they tortured and murdered them by shooting or slitting their throats. Several people were castrated and decapitated with chainsaws, most of the bodies were dismembered and thrown into the Guaviare river with rocks inside their stomachs so that they could not be found. The precise amount of mortal victims has not been established, there are at least 20 disappeared and more than 70% of Mapiripán’s inhabitants were massively displaced.
In 2005 the Inter American Court of Human Rights declared the international responsibility of Colombia for the actions occurred in Mapiripán. By 2019 approximately 37% of all the reparations ordered by the Court had been implemented [RobledoSilva, 2019; Vivas and Toro, 2016]. One of the reparations with moral intention mandated was to:
build an appropriate and dignified monument in remembrance of the facts in the Mapiripán Massacre, as a measure to prevent such grave events happening in the future. Said monument must be placed in an appropriate public space in Mapiripán, within a year of notification of the Judgment.

In 19 July, 2009, during a massive ceremony to commemorate 12 years of the massacre, victims’ organisations, families and supporters installed the monument you see in the picture above (Figure 1) in a corner on a public street close to a field used as landing track [El Tiempo, 2009]. The sculpture was entitled La sangre de nuestros mártires renacerá la nueva patria, which literally means The blood of our martyrs will reborn the new motherland. The sculptor Luis Alfredo Castañeda was chosen by the victims to lead the project, he worked with them to materialise their expectations. The monument is a monolithic object 3 meters high made of glass fibre with a golden finish, essentially a clenched left fist representing hope and civil resistance against violence. According to the artist the monument reflects the courageous and resilient identity of part of the community. Nevertheless, the sculpture does not offer an account of the facts, neither of the experiences of victims or their families. It does not challenge the stigma on this village as guerrilla collaborators that contributed to their targeting. In fact, the fist (as the monument is populary called) has created uneasiness in some inhabitants because it is seen as a symbol of leftist orientation which, in an area still plagued with paramilitaries, could put Mapiripán’s community in danger (actually in 2002 there was another massacre in the village for the same alleged guerrilla collaboration).
In 2017 the sculpture was intentionally destroyed and it is still damaged nowadays (see Figure 2). The attack on the monument occurred a couple of months after the Colombian Prosecutor Office closed an investigation on this case, founding that at least 16 of the 26 victims plenty identified in the sentence could be alive or could not have been killed in the massacre. This investigation contributed to the controversy already created by the monument.

The destruction has been described as revictimising, making it lose any reparative character it could have had before. The local administration plans to move the monument to a location not approved by the victims due to their concern about the lack of visibility and the propensity to flooding of the chosen land. Furthermore, victims’ organisations in Mapiripán have proposed to construct a Memory House instead of a new or repaired monument, that could also release the tension created by the fist within the community.
To this day there are no settled plans for the monument to be a monument again.
To learn more:
Case of the Mapiripan Massacre v. Colombia. (Merits, Reparations and
Costs) 15 September 2005. IACtHR Series C No. 134.
Aksenova, M. (2020). Creative Potential of Reparations at the Inter-American Court of Human Rights and the International Criminal Court. Suffolk Transnational Law Review, 43(1):1–10.
El Tiempo (2017). Con 12 judicializados, cierran ciclo de falsas víctimas de Mapiripán.
El Tiempo (2009). Mapiripán recordó los 12 años de la masacre paramilitar en Meta.
Robledo-Silva, P. (2019). Radiografía del cumplimiento de las sentencias de la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos en los casos relacionados con el conflicto armado colombiano. In Correa, M. and Palacios, A., editors, El Estado Constitucional Colombiano en la Periferia. Tomo 1, pages 62–96. Publicaciones Universidad Externado de Colombia
Rutas del Conflicto (2019). Masacre de Mapiripán 1997.
Sierra-León, Y. (2021). Teoría general de la reparación simbólica. Universidad Externado, Bogotá.
Uribe Sanabria, C. and Restrepo Ortiz, N. (2013). Could the Inter American human rights system have prevented the existence of false victims in the mapiripán case? International Law, Revista Colombiana de Derecho Internacional, (23):203–234.
Vivas, T. and Toro, E. (2016). Análisis de caso: estudio sobre el cumplimiento de la sentencia masacre de Mapiripán contra Colombia. Revista Prolegómenos Derechos y Valores.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Next week El Salado




Comments