top of page
Search

19 Comerciantes

Mar 16, 2025
4 min read

On 7th October, 1987, 17 men dedicated to buying and selling goods on the Colombian-Venezuelan border were detained by members of the Colombian military forces in collusion with the paramilitary group Autodefensas de Puerto Boyacá, alleging the merchants had relations with guerrilla groups. The 17 men were murdered and dismembered, and their bodies thrown into a river. Two weeks later, two more merchants who went to the area looking for the first group were also killed.

Almost 17 years later, in 2004, the IACtHR decided on the case ordering the Colombian state to implement reparations for the families of the disappeared.


As the sentence declares:

most of the next of kin of the alleged victims have stated that they need a form of acknowledgment by society, such as a monument or some publicly identified place, which recognizes the dignity of the tradesmen and also provides some kind of public expression.

Accordingly, one of the reparations with moral intent ordered in the sentence was the construction of a monument with a plaque containing the names of the 19 victims and located in a public place agreed by the parties. The said monument (Figure 1) was finished in 2011 but due to poor state logistics its placement and official inauguration was delayed until 2013, and only after the families resorted to additional legal measures to force the government to comply with the mandate.


Figure 1: Monument to the 19 Merchants (photo on the left Sara Morales, right Agencia EFE, all rights reserved 2013).


Although the idea of constructing a monument as a form of reparation was suggested by the victims during the process in the Inter American system, negotiating the details with the state, after the sentence, was difficult. In June 2005 the state, without previous consultation, presented a design of a monument that consisted in a obelisk of 3 by 2 meters; the families rejected that idea because that obelisk did not satisfy the objectives of the measure of reparation. After that, the state selected the sculptor Juan Manuel Arreaza for the project. At least another artist presented a design but it was not shared with the families and it is unclear how Arreaza was chosen. Arreaza presented his own design to the families and made some changes to that initial proposal according to their suggestions. Finally, the monument was located in a public park, although not on the place selected by the families from the three options given to them, instead the location was imposed by the local government.


The actual sculpture (see Figure 1) portraits 12 dark life-size adult human figures (including a woman) made of bronze and mounted on a pedestal. The figures seem to be clinging to each other forming some kind of human pyramid in which the one on the top holds a small child on his arms. The agreed design included a water mirror with night illumination to project seven additional figures--making a total of 19--; however the necessary installation of light and water flow were not built due to alleged financial constrains by local authorities, showing their lack of commitment with the project. The impression left by this sculpture is that of a group of people trying to escape from some natural disaster that requires being in a higher position to be safe.


The sculpture itself does not make references to any experience or identity traits of victims, neither alludes to what happened or who was responsible; in fact locals believe this monument honours victims of another infamous massacre in the same region (namely La Rochela massacre). The only reference to the events is a brief inscription on a plaque that was entirely financed by the families:

The 19 merchants who disappeared on 7 October, 1987 do not rest here because their remains have not yet been found. This is, however, a monument to their memory and against oblivion so that the world knows and the society and the Colombian State remember that such atrocious events should not be repeated. The greatest punishment for those responsible is that they will never be absolved by their own conscience.

The names of the disappeared are listed in another plaque (paid by the state) which was stolen in 2016 and replaced in 2017.

After the inauguration event, which was not properly advertised to the public and conveyed only a few people, at least two commemoration acts have been made in the same place (in 2014 and 2018), showing some level of ownership of the monument as a memory site. With the monument now installed, some families recount their satisfaction with having a place to honour their lost ones; but they also express their disappointment with the low capacity of the monument to give an account of the facts and their indignation with its poor maintenance. Another relative declared that the monument and the inauguration event are significant in as much as they open the door for the truth and justice to come, which is what they are still waiting for. In any case, the disagreements during the whole process and the delay in installing the monument created sadness, rage, and impotence on the victims; somehow curtailing the reparative experience of this monument.



To learn more about this case:

Case of 19 Merchants v. Colombia. (Merits, Reparations and Costs) 5 July 2004. IACtHR ser C No. 109.

Caso 19 Comerciantes vs Colombia. Supervisión de cumplimiento de sentencia.

Resolución CIDH 21 de noviembre de 2023.

Corte Constitucional Colombia. Sentence T-653 23 August 2012.

Casas-Casas, A. and Herrera-Toloza, G. (2008). El juego político de las

transicional. Papel Político, 13(1):197–223.

Justicia y Paz Colombia (2022). Desaparición forzada de 19 comerciantes.



-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Next week the monument for the victims of Mapiripan massacre.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page