Monument to Life
Updated: Mar 20, 2025
The sculpture below (Figure 1) is entitled Monumento a la vida (Monument to Life). Look at it. What does it tell you?
Figure 1. Different perspectives of Monumento a la vida (photos Esculturas de Colombia, all rights reserved 2016).
There are children enjoying their time, playing carelessly under the sunlight. Not quite the situation that originated the monument.
This sculpture is a monument erected to remember and pay homage to the victims of what is known as Villatina massacre which occurred in the early 80s in the city of Medellin, Colombia. In the evening of 15th November 1992, a group of police officers wearing civilian clothes arrived in Villatina, a shanty neighbourhood of Medellín, and shot indiscriminately against a group of people seating on the street. Eight minors and one young adult were killed.
Families of the victims started a process before the Inter American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) which led to the signature of a friendly settlement in 29 July 2002 (the agreement was followed up and ratified by the report Petition 11141. Villatina Massacre IACHR Report No. 105/05, OEA/Ser.L/V/II.124 Doc. 5. 27 October, 2005). The agreement contains a list of all reparations agreed between the parties; by 2020 all of them were implemented and the settlement was declared complete. One of the actions agreed as measure of collective reparation linked to the recovery of memory was the construction of a monument, which was unveiled in 2004.
According to the settlement, the creation of the monument should comply with certain requirements: it should be made in bronze, it should integrate nine elements clearly identifiable as the victims, and the project should include proper adaptation of the public space to be used. Regarding the artist in charge the agreement foresaw selecting one with some personal or professional experience in the field of human rights. For that selection `the petitioners and the Office of the Mayor of Medellin shall each submit two names of artists to invite them to present proposals'. Unfortunately, those parameters were not strictly applied. The responsible artist was selected through a public contest in which the artist preferred by the victims was not even invited to participate. According to the research undertaken by Angélica Zamora in 2009, the families would have preferred the monument to be designed by Adriana Lalinde, sister of Luis Fernando Lalinde--a victim of enforced disappearance--(another case brought before the Inter American system at that time).
Under the limited options available, the victims reluctantly supported the design proposed by Edgar Gamboa, although the artist did not have the right profile and his design did not fulfil their requirements regarding the number of figures represented and its whole impression was not appealing to them. The monument is now located on a busy central square called Parque del periodista (Journalist park). Despite not being the location preferred by the families, that park was in fact one of the possible options on the settlement.
The monument consists of four mimetic bronze statues of children, in and around a ribbed globe sustained by nine circular arks with the name of each victim inscribed on them. The four figures represent a dancing girl; a boy playing with a soccer ball, another boy seating on the steps at the basis of the globe with an old cassette player on his shoulder; and the last boy reading on a public bench in front of the globe. The monument captures these children enjoying their pastimes as described by some mothers on their declarations. However, those actions are represented in an idealised version and do not correspond to the reality of the victims' experiences as members of a marginalised community. The children depicted are much more younger than the real victims (five of them were 17, the others 15, 16, 22, and 8) which accentuates the misrepresentation of the massacre as police's error and not as an extended practice of targeting young men in poor neighbourhoods as a cleaning strategy.
A plaque attached to the monument includes the names and ages of each victim and the date of their killing followed by this inscription:
The Colombian Government recognized its responsibility to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights of the OAS and to the Colombian society for the violation of human rights in this serious crime, attributable to State agents. This monument is a way to commemorate the victims, make moral amends and express atonement to the families, and although it is not enough to ease the pain produced by this action, it has become a fundamental step for justice to be done and to remind Colombians that crimes of this nature cannot be repeated.
As the text shows, the Colombian state recognised its responsibility for the massacre; however, as some mothers claim, there has been no justice since none of the police officers involved in the crime has been judged. Despite the plaque, most people who visit the park is not aware of the monument's context or purpose; thus the monument has a weak social impact, it does not promote any critical questioning about the event and it does not contribute to preserve the memory of the victims.
Relatives of the victims complain about the environment in which the monument is erected often with people drinking and consuming drugs whilst siting around the monument. Most of the families have expressed their disappointment with the monument not only due to its poor expressive performance but also questioning the usefulness of such type of reparation given their precarious economical situation.
The case of the monument for the Villatina massacre exhibits the complexities of negotiating this kind of reparations. Such a process requires not only an active involvement of victims and political willingness from state representatives, but also a careful consideration of what the monument is expected to communicate or express to both victims and society.
To learn more:
Zamora-Prieto, A. (2009). La reparación a partir de la experiencia de las víctimas: los casos de Villatina y Trujillo. In Díaz, C., Sánchez, N., and Uprimny, R., editors, Reparar en Colombia: los dilemas en contextos de conflicto, pobreza y exclusión. ICTJ–DeJusticia.
Mégrét, F. (2010). Of shrines, memorials and museums : using the International Criminal Court’s victim reparation and assistance regime to promote transitional justice. Buffalo Human Rights Law Review, 16(16):1-56
Museo Casa de la Memoria (2016). Haciendo Memoria, construyendo nuestra historia Monumento Villatina.
Hora 13, N. (2017). 25 años después, madres de nueve niños masacrados en Villatina todavía claman por justicia.
Rutas del Conflicto (2019h). Masacre de Villatina.
Reyes, A. M. (2019). The Monument to the Children of Villatina: commemorating innocent child victims in the context of lethally stigmatized youth in Colombia. Visual Communication, 18(3):379–398.
Reyes, A. M., Laplante, L., Orwicz, M., Falconi, J., Rosenberg, F., and Greeley, R. (2020). Repairing Symbolic Reparations: Assessing the Effectiveness of Memorialization in the Inter American System of Human Rights. International Journal of Transitional Justice, 14(1):165–192.
TeleMedellín, N. (2022). Se cumplen 30 años de la masacre de Villatina.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Next week the monument for the 19 Merchants.




Comments